Listening challenge: Software vs hardware synths

Only one of our clips was recorded on a real Minimoog...
Only one of our clips was recorded on a real Minimoog...

When software developers started emulating classic synths and packing them into plug-ins, there was only ever going to be one big debate: do they sound the same as the original instruments?

The argument has run and run, with some claiming to be able to tell the difference straight away, and others saying that, in terms of sound, the virtual versions are practically indistinguishable from the hardware that inspired them.

But what do you think? We want you to listen to the three Minimoog bass clips below and tell us which one you think was recorded on the original synth. The other two were created using Minimoog software emulations:

Clip A

Clip B

Clip C

Click here for the results of the listening challenge

The MusicRadar team

MusicRadar is the number 1 website for music makers of all kinds, be they guitarists, drummers, keyboard players, djs or producers...

  • GEAR: We help musicians find the best gear with top-ranking gear round-ups and high- quality, authoritative reviews by a wide team of highly experienced experts.
  • TIPS: We also provide tuition, from bite-sized tips to advanced work-outs and guidance from recognised musicians and stars.
  • STARS: We talk to musicians and stars about their creative processes, and the nuts and bolts of their gear and technique. We give fans an insight into the actual craft of music making that no other music website can.