As is well documented in the Some Kind of Monster movie, there was the exit of Jason Newstead, creative tug-of-war between James Hetfield (himself struggling with alcohol addiction and subsequent rehab) and Lars Ulrich, constant in-fighting between the members.
Then there was Dr Phil Towle, who seemingly lost all sense of his official position of band counsellor as he started chipping in on ideas for songs.
Upon the album’s release, the metal titans suffered the backlash of fans and detractors alike - accusations of severe shark jumping as the already-dying nu-metal influences were there in spades. No guitar solos, bouncy down-tuned riffs, pseudo-nu-metal vocal flourishes. But for drummers: that snare drum.
While it’s commonly stated that Lars ‘achieved’ the sound by turning his snares off with the drum tuned up, there is some audible snap from the snares, suggesting that perhaps they weren’t completely off. Besides, as demonstrated by Danny Carey, loose snares do not a bad hard-rock snare drum sound make.
16 years on, Lars’ snare sound from St. Anger remains a heavily-criticised feature of the album, and an often-used example of a bad snare sound. However, we’re willing to wager that the snare in a different context wouldn’t have caused such outrage. It’s cranked, wide-open, dry and ringing: in other words if you close your eyes, it’s not far off Chad Smith’s snare sound.
The problem here, is this is Metallica. The band whose snare drum punches you in the face with its dead, fat, huge roomy sound. Is the St. Anger snare awful? Subjective.
Does it sound out of context for what we’re used to from Metallica? Yes. But we think Lars gets the rough end of his signature sticks with this one, as so much of the sound is in the hands of production.
It’s a debate that will likely never end. So for now, enjoy Cameron Fluery's cover of Frantic, featuring a bin lid mic’d up as a snare drum.