Skip to main content
MusicRadar MusicRadar The No.1 website for musicians
Sign in
  • View Profile
  • Sign out
  • Drums Week 25
  • Synths
  • Guitars
  • Guitar Pedals
  • Guitar Amps
  • Keyboards & Pianos
  • Controllers
  • Artist news
  • Drums
  • Software & Apps
  • More
    • Recording
    • DJ Gear
    • Acoustic Guitars
    • Bass Guitars
    • Tech
    • Tutorials
    • Reviews
    • Buying Guides
    • About Us
More
  • Santana on Beck
  • Friday, I'm in Love
  • Knopfler's 4-note secret
  • 95k+ free music samples
Don't miss these
Clem Burke, Ancienne Belgique (AB), Brussels, Belgium, November 1998
Drummers Clem Burke's 10 essential drum albums
Drummers Listen to 11 isolated drum tracks from rock's drumming legends
Danny Carey
Drummers 6 of the most inspirational drummers of all time
Drummers When British rock drumming ruled the world
From Bobby Z to Hannah F
Drummers The many drummers of Prince
Hal Blaine
Drummers Read our classic interview with Wrecking Crew legend Hal Blaine
Ray Cooper
Artists Percussionist Ray Cooper tells the story of his ‘lost’ live collaboration with Elton John
mitch mitchell
Artists The magic of Mitch Mitchell, the drummer who landed a spot in Hendrix’s band on a coin toss
There's a joke here somewhere
Drummers 21 of the best drummer jokes ever
Drum Recording Techniques
Drums How the rules of drum recording were shaped over decades of trial and error
Side profile of a person playing a drum kit
Drum Lessons & Tutorials 13 easy drum songs every beginner should learn
Jeff Porcaro
Artists Exploring the genius of Jeff Porcaro's Rosanna Shuffle
Photo of Mike JOYCE and SMITHS and MORRISSEY and Andy ROURKE and Johnny MARR; L-R: Andy Rourke, Mike Joyce (drums), Morrissey, Johnny Marr (playing Gibson ES-335 guitar), performing live on The Tube
Drummers “This book truly conveys what it felt like to be a member of the Smiths”: Mike Joyce’s memoir to be published in November
View from behind a drum kit on stage
Drummers 11 live mistakes every drummer makes
Ringo Starr
Drummers Ringo Starr names his proudest moment in The Beatles
  1. Artists
  2. Drummers

6 career defining records of Mel Gaynor

News
By David West published 27 January 2010

Simple Minds' drummer picks his finest

When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s how it works.

Mel Gaynor

Mel Gaynor

Mel Gaynor came to fame when he joined Simple Minds as a session drummer in 1982, giving the Scottish rockers a jolt of power in the process. Of course, Gaynor got the full-time gig and the rest, as they say, is history.

Here Mel Gaynor shares the six records which have most defined his career as a drummer, telling Rhythm Magazine why they mattered so much along the way.

Next: becoming "louder than Motorhead"

Page 1 of 7
Page 1 of 7
Sparkle In The Rain (1984)

Sparkle In The Rain (1984)

After splitting the drumming on 1982’s New Gold Dream, Mel established his place in Simple Minds with the follow-up, produced by Steve Lillywhite.

Mel Gaynor says:

“It put the stamp on the Simple Minds drum sound. We got a great sound on that record. It was the turnaround album from New Gold Dream, which I thought was very quiet, staid and straight as far as the drums went. This album was really fun. It was recorded in the old Townhouse studios, which apparently used to be a swimming pool.”

“It was the Phil Collins, In The Air Tonight sound. That was the first time I started to write with the band and the time when the drums were at the forefront. I remember Radio One saying it was the loudest record on the radio, louder than Motörhead. We were like, ‘Yeah, that’s great! We’re turning into a rock band!’”

“I’m a pretty adaptable player; I don’t play loud all the time. It’s down to the music and the artist, but that was a loud album. That was from Steve Lillywhite wanting it loud.”

Page 2 of 7
Page 2 of 7
Once Upon A Time (1985)

Once Upon A Time (1985)

Recorded in Bearsville Studios, New York, with producers Bob Clearmountain and Jimmy Iovine, Once Upon A Time spawned the huge hit Alive And Kicking. To top it off, the band played Live Aid straight after.

Mel Gaynor says:

“We really took the time to sort out the songs and find some great ideas. I was completely blown away by the sounds Bob Clearmountain got. I guess there was a lot of pressure, but it was from the commercial side.”

“Sparkle In The Rain was very experimental. Now we wanted to get the hits so there was pressure to come up with more singles on that album. We were cracking the American market, which was very important so there was a big transition at that time.”

“The studio was in the middle of nowhere. We spent the best part of five months in it, then came out and went straight into Live Aid. I remember being introduced by Jack Nicholson - that was a real buzz. One of the pinnacles for me was seeing Neil Young and Led Zeppelin. It was a great day.”

Page 3 of 7
Page 3 of 7
Secret Secrets (1985)

Secret Secrets (1985)

The rhythm section for Joan Armatrading’s 12th album was firing on all cylinders, with Mel on the kit and Pino Palladino on bass.

Mel Gaynor says:

“I got a call from Joan Armatrading’s management asking if I could do the album. I was a big fan of her work, so it was a pleasure to play with her. There was some slight confusion at the beginning because she wanted me to play like the demos, which had drum machines. I basically told her, ‘I’m not a drum machine, so I don’t play like a drum machine’.”

“It was an unusual session. She got Joe Jackson in, who’s a very talented keyboard player, but I didn’t know that at the time. We did a Latin track with him and it was incredible. I always remember that day with Joe. It was an all-round great session and to top it all I got her to play me a version of Love And Affection, just as a one-to-one.”

“She wanted me to do some live dates but I didn’t have the time.”

Page 4 of 7
Page 4 of 7
Ice On Fire (1985)

Ice On Fire (1985)

Mel had the chance to play with a key member of the elite pantheon of British pop when he recorded the album Ice On Fire with Elton John (not yet knighted, so no ‘Sir’ at this point).

Mel Gaynor says:

“He was a real gentleman to work with and I was picked out of the bag to do that album along with a great bass player called Deon Estus. That was a memorable album to do because there were great songs, a great singer and piano player, and it was a great location.”

“It was in Surrey at Gus Dudgeon’s studio out in the countryside. There were a few pointers arrangement-wise, but as far as playing went, it was left up to us. I worked with a couple of loops and sequences, but it was still very organic. It wasn’t completely computerised - there was still a human feel to it.”

“We played as a band and Elton played with us so we’d get a great feel, as opposed to just getting a drum take. If there were drop-ins, I’d go back and drop-in over that, rather than just going for the perfect drum take.”

Page 5 of 7
Page 5 of 7
Real Life (1991)

Real Life (1991)

“Real Life came back to the real Simple Minds sound,” says Mel, who cut the record using a custom-built fibreglass kit. Showing his versatility, Mel broke out the brushes for the haunting ballad Woman.

Mel Gaynor says:

“Real Life was a great album to record. It came after Street Fighting Years, which was okay, but as far as the drums went it was very staid. We had Steve Lipson working with us and he got some really fantastic sounds on this album.”

“I had a Pearl fibreglass kit, which was kind of a one-off. I went to Japan and just picked out some shells that were lying around in the factory. It was a very loud kit but it had a warm tone. It was a pity I never got a snare drum to go with it. I should have, because it would have been unique.”

“Woman was quite strange, I wasn’t sure how to track it but it turned out alright in the end. It started off with a drum machine and I came in with brushes. The full kit was too overpowering, so I just added texture over the top.”

Page 6 of 7
Page 6 of 7
Graffiti Soul (2009)

Graffiti Soul (2009)

“The music has changed quite a lot,” says Mel, 27 years after his Simple Minds debut.

Mel Gaynor says:

“The bass and keyboard players have changed and new people coming in has given a freshness to everybody’s playing.” “Graffiti Soul was actually two records in one. Because it was going so well, we decided to do a covers album as well.”

“One favourite of mine is Rockin’ In The Free World. I was pretty buzzed about doing that song and Jim sang it really well. It was a very relaxed album, so there wasn’t too much stress. Despite that, we tracked 20 songs in about 10 days, really going for it.”

“My playing hasn’t changed too much. What has changed is my attitude towards music because I’m a songwriter now. I write on keyboards and bass. I’ve always connected with the bass and it’s great to know where the bass is coming from.”

Page 7 of 7
Page 7 of 7
Categories
Drums
David West
Read more
Clem Burke, Ancienne Belgique (AB), Brussels, Belgium, November 1998
Clem Burke's 10 essential drum albums
Listen to 11 isolated drum tracks from rock's drumming legends
Danny Carey
6 of the most inspirational drummers of all time
When British rock drumming ruled the world
From Bobby Z to Hannah F
The many drummers of Prince
Hal Blaine
Read our classic interview with Wrecking Crew legend Hal Blaine
Latest in Drummers
Josh Freese performs onstage with The Vandals during day 1 of Warped Tour at Shoreline Waterfront on July 26, 2025
“It wasn’t music that I really resonated with”: Josh Freese lifts the lid on his exit from the Foo Fighters
Photo of Mike JOYCE and SMITHS and MORRISSEY and Andy ROURKE and Johnny MARR; L-R: Andy Rourke, Mike Joyce (drums), Morrissey, Johnny Marr (playing Gibson ES-335 guitar), performing live on The Tube
“This book truly conveys what it felt like to be a member of the Smiths”: Mike Joyce’s memoir to be published in November
Drum Recording Techniques
How the rules of drum recording were shaped over decades of trial and error
Neil Peart performing with Rush in 2012
“To those I inspired to start drumming, I apologise to your parents!”: A rare interview with Rush legend Neil Peart
Simon Dawson
“We didn’t want a clone”: Bruce Dickinson on why Maiden chose a drummer with a different feel
Danny Carey
6 of the most inspirational drummers of all time
Latest in News
Sebastian Bach performs on Day 1 of the Heavy Montreal festival at Parc Jean-Drapeau on August 6, 2016 in Montreal, Canada
“I could kick 'em right in the balls”: Ex-Skid Row man goes on a rant about Youtube armchair critics
Composer John Williams
“I never liked film music very much”: World famous film composer makes startling admission
Deals of the week
MusicRadar deals of the week: Here are the best Labor Day sales for musicians from across the internet
Boss PX-1 Plugout FX: the white compact series pedal has blue knobs, digital display, and is a platform for 16 digitally modelled Boss effects, one of which is available at a time.
A compact series stompbox you can turn into any one of 16 classic Boss effects? Meet the Plugout FX
Zak Starkey and Axl Rose composite
“C’mon bro... It could generate $2M for teen cancer”: Zak Starkey pleads with Axl Rose to give the go-ahead for charity cover of Bolan classic
Don Felder plays his iconic white Gibson doubleneck electric guitar onstage. Note the double jack: that mod is crucial when playing Hotel California, which he surely is in this picture.
Don Felder on why he had to mod his white Gibson doubleneck to play the Eagles’ biggest hit – and how he got the idea from Chet Atkins

MusicRadar is part of Future plc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. Visit our corporate site.

  • About Us
  • Contact Future's experts
  • Terms and conditions
  • Privacy policy
  • Cookies policy
  • Advertise with us
  • Accessibility Statement
  • Careers

© Future Publishing Limited Quay House, The Ambury, Bath BA1 1UA. All rights reserved. England and Wales company registration number 2008885.

Please login or signup to comment

Please wait...