tweet

Metallica's camp say "the band are happy" with Death Magnetic

Yet fans' online protests continue

Chris Vinnicombe, Wed 17 Sep 2008, 5:55 pm UTC

Metallica's camp say 'the band are happy' with Death Magnetic

We bought our copy last Thursday, a day before the original 12 September worldwide release date

View in gallery

It's been a busy few days for Metallica. On the one hand, they've released their best and most talked-about LP for 17 years and it's topped charts on either side of the atlantic, selling hundreds of thousands of copies in the process.

However, to a band who have faced more than their fair share of drama and controversy over the years it will probably come as no surprise that the release of Death Magnetic hasn't gone by without a hitch or two. 

Yesterday, we revealed the growing disquiet surrounding the audio quality of the CD release, along with the revelation that many fans seem to prefer the way Death Magnetic sounds in the Guitar Hero 3 video game. There's even a petition demanding that the album be remixed or remastered

As the debate rumbles on in the online community and starts to be picked up by the mainstream media, it's surely high time that somebody in the Metallica camp had something to say to all of the fans who love the songs on Death Magnetic but feel short-changed by a distorted, punishingly loud CD master.

"As far as i'm aware the band are happy with the quality of the album and everyone I know who has it, thinks it sounds fantastic."

Metallica have been in the UK for a couple of days promoting Death Magnetic with a busy promotional schedule including a live date at the O2 Arena (read our review here) and an appearance on Later...With Jools Holland.

The first official word  

We spoke to one of the band's UK press representatives who had this to say about the uproar surrounding Death Magnetic:

"I've seen all the stories, and will ask if anyone wants to comment, although the band tend to deal with questions via their website, and comment on there. As far as i'm aware the band are happy with the quality of the album and everyone I know who has it, thinks it sounds fantastic.

"It looks like the album will be number one again in the UK next week, which I guess wouldn't be happening if people felt the album wasn't up to scratch."

It seems that for the time being, fans will just have to sit tight and wait for the band to respond. 

Share:
StumbleUpon
Digg
Reddit
Del.icio.us

User comments (2)

  • Mox

    Avatar for Mox

    Fri 19 Sep 2008, 1:45 pm UTC

    MetalMod (and everybody else), I thought so too .. thought it a storm in a teacup, audiophiles complaining - untill I heard the Guitar Hero mixes. Believe me, you don't know what you're missing. Even on the crappiest sound system it's light years better than the CD. Nuances, the awesome quality of the playing - to me Death Magnetic is a masterpiece now, but it is totally buried in distortion on the CD. Very sad. I just hope some kind of comment from the band will surface soon. Not knowing their take on this is seriously frustrating - why would they work for years to produce a brlliant album, and then allow it to be slaughtered like this? Do they really want it to sound that way??

    Mark as inappropriate

  • MetalMod

    Avatar for MetalMod

    Wed 17 Sep 2008, 8:06 pm UTC

    my copy seems alright, i have no qualms with the mix

    Mark as inappropriate

You need to be logged in to post a comment. Login or Register to post a comment.

Poll

Ask MusicRadar: You chose the top 15, now pick the winner. What's the greatest guitar riff off all time?

ReviewFinder

Search by product, brand or manufacturer

Buy here

  • Buy music products with Red Dog Music
  • Buy music products with Professional Music Technology
  • Buy music products with Thomann
  • Buy music products with Andertons Music Company
  • Buy music products with Hartnolls Guitars

MusicRadar Marketplace

If you're looking for great deals on gear, tuition, mastering, education or kit hire, click here for our new and improved marketplace.

Follow us on twitter Sign up for our free newsletter Have your say on the MusicRadar forums