Ernie Ball Music Man St Vincent review

A Music Man with Annie Clark’s seal of approval

  • £2,299
  • $1,899

MusicRadar Verdict

This beautifully-made guitar shows the danger of judging a book by its cover.


  • +

    Wonderfully well-made.

  • +

    Neck is a work of art.


  • -

    Shape might not get your heart racing.

MusicRadar's got your back Our team of expert musicians and producers spends hours testing products to help you choose the best music-making gear for you. Find out more about how we test.

 Music Man is becoming known for its far-from-mainstream shapes and styles, but the St Vincent makes instruments such as Albert Lee’s long-running angular signature model - a guitar that was Annie Clark’s introduction to the brand - seem like a comfy ol’ Stratocaster.  

“A couple of years ago they sent me the Albert Lee,” she tells us, “and when I was touring with David Byrne for the record Love This Giant, I fell in love with it, because it’s so versatile. On that particular tour, I was transitioning from lead to rhythm, to making sounds, so I had to be part session-player/part frontman. That guitar had the tonal versatility and fret versatility to be a lot of things.”  

At first glance, it might not be a shape you aspire to - although it does share a family resemblance to Music Man’s forward-looking Armada - but its studied elegance is hugely impressive, a sort of Firebird-meets-Explorer put through St Vincent’s stylistic mangle.  

The neck is as close to a work of art as we’ve seen.

 “My design aesthetic for it is based around what was happening in the 1960s and the 1980s, and what was happening in Japan in the 1970s, as far as the look of guitars goes. If you look further back in history, the work of artists like [Kazimir] Malevich were also an inspiration.”  

As was her old Harmony: “Yes, the Harmony Bobkat! What I love about that guitar is that it was super-light, and the whammy bar on it was really unique. So that was another guitar inspiration for the signature model.”  While some modernist designs can feel as odd as they look, the African mahogany bodied St Vincent is both beautifully weighted (3.52kg/7.74lb) and hangs really well on a strap with the lower bass-side edge very comfortable under your forearm.  

There’s a conventional rear ribcage cut; the forearm contour itself is an angled chamfer, not curved like a Strat, while the treble side control area is angled to a slightly lesser extent - the straight lines of the upper bouts extending to a point at the base, enhancing the ‘no curves here’ geometry. 

There’s no cutaway as such: the top treble-side shoulder joins the bolt-on rosewood neck at the 19th fret; the heel barely moves out from the higher bass-side shoulder and, typically, is beautifully shaped, and fixed with Music Man’s usual five-screw joint.  

In fact, the neck is as close to a work of art as we’ve seen. The oiled and waxed rosewood feels hugely engaging to the touch and the deep rounded ‘D’ shape is instantly attractive - slightly thinner in depth (21mm at the 1st fret; 22.7mm at the 12th) than Music Man’s recently introduced Cutlass and StingRay, which share the same 648mm (25.5-inch) scale length.  “The Albert Lee has such a phenomenal neck,” Annie continues, “and you can really sing on that neck. When I was given the opportunity to create my own guitar, one of the things that I wanted to keep was the neck-feel of that Albert Lee.”  

New Horizons 

The 254mm (10-inch) radius fingerboard, a separate piece of rosewood, has perfectly installed high-profile medium-gauge frets and those custom-designed connected double ‘O’ inlays. The headstock does look small, but string-pull is straight over the compensated nut to the locking tuners with their tasteful pearloid buttons. It’s a hugely considered piece. 

Of course, at the other end of the string is that modern Music Man vibrato - here, with a slightly pointed cover - while the trio of custom DiMarzio mini-humbuckers are a typically idiosyncratic choice; the neck and middle are suspended on the generously sized, thick plastic scratchplate, and the bridge unit is screwed directly to the body. 

The headstock does look small, but string-pull is straight over the compensated nut to the locking tuners with their tasteful pearloid buttons. It’s a hugely considered piece.

Even the control knobs are custom made, another beautiful detail. Under the hood, we have a standard five-way pickup selector, with its Strat-like selections - the pots are 250k with .047 microfarad tone cap, more Fender single coil than Gibson humbucker. 

Its acoustic response is a little ‘drier’, more acoustic-y than the Cutlass and StingRay, but once again, intonation and setup are exceptional. Sonically, we have an old-school signal path with no tricks, and compared with the Cutlass we have a bit more oomph and a rounder, darker high-end. 

But, as ever with three pickups wired like this, you can’t help referencing a Strat, albeit with this different core tonality. Clean, therefore, the St Vincent does sound a little dark, though rich, resonant and beautifully sustaining with a fruity midrange. Switching from classic Fender clean to the meat of a driven Marshall, there’s a hugely impressive thickness, but without the low-end ‘thump’ of a typical single-cut. Even at modest volumes it sounds huge. 

Annie certainly has her own sonic stew in mind, but remove the vibrato arm and this is a slide-playing tour-de-force. It just proves, once again, that if you judge a guitar by its cover alone, then you are in danger of seriously missing out. 

Dave Burrluck

Dave Burrluck is one of the world’s most experienced guitar journalists, who started writing back in the '80s for International Musician and Recording World, co-founded The Guitar Magazine and has been the Gear Reviews Editor of Guitarist magazine for the past two decades. Along the way, Dave has been the sole author of The PRS Guitar Book and The Player's Guide to Guitar Maintenance as well as contributing to numerous other books on the electric guitar. Dave is an active gigging and recording musician and still finds time to make, repair and mod guitars, not least for Guitarist’s The Mod Squad.