The place for music makers
The new Mac mini, iMac and Mac Pro compared
Ben Rogerson, Tue 10 Mar 2009, 9:39 am UTC
Last week, Apple refreshed its entire range of desktop computers, improving the specs of its Mac mini, iMac and Mac Pro models.
All of these machines ship with GarageBand '09 (plus the rest of the iLife '09 apps), which means that you could easily make music with any of them. However, we're going to examine all the machines' strengths and weaknesses and help you to decide which of the new Macs is right for you.
We'll look at each model in turn, before drawing some conclusions. Prices shown are for the entry-level models – if you want better specs, you'll have to pay more.

The baby of the Apple desktop family now has a faster processor and a larger hard drive, which is certainly good news for music makers. However, as with the other machines, the improved graphics won't concern tunesmiths too much. Unlike the MacBook, the Mac mini retains a FireWire port (800), and there are also five USB 2.0 ports. Early reports suggest that it lives up to its billing as "the world's most energy-efficient desktop computer".
For: Tiny and cute; environmentally friendly; the cheapest desktop Mac you can buy.
Against: Only 1GB of RAM in the entry-level model; limited expansion options; not as affordable as we'd like; no mouse or keyboard; you'll have to provide the display, too.

The only desktop Mac to come with its own display, the 24-inch model – which is the same price as its 20-inch predecessor - is the one to look at if you're a musician (you'll definitely feel the benefit of that additional screen real estate). Getting 4GB of RAM and a 640GB hard drive as standard should ensure decent performance and give you plenty of room to store your audio.
For: Ready to use out of the box; looks lovely; decent value for money; you now get the big-screen version at a lower price.
Against: Limited expansion options; you can't take the display with you when you buy your next computer.

This is indisputably the most powerful Mac you can buy, so logic dictates that it's also the most capable Apple-branded music machine. The latest Mac Pro is available in Quad-Core and 8-Core configurations, with all machines being powered by Intel's Xeon 'Nehalem' processors. A redesigned interior means it's now easier than ever to expand this high-end monster.
For: Seriously powerful; Massive expansion potential (if you want to install a PCI Express card, this is your only Apple option).
Against: Expensive; a display will cost you extra if you don't already have one.
SOS, Future Music and the rest of the music press pretty much confirms the fact that the vast majority of Pros seem to use Macs & Logic
It's somewhat frustrating to read this with 'every single issue' though, especially knowing that even the cheapest Mac option is going to cost a small fortune. No a 'big' fortune
Assuming the Mac Mini is out, the cheapest alternative is a 'Bottom' of the range iMac and whilst they are good, it's a lot of cash to spend on something which you can barely upgrade in the future and as you say you can't reuse the display with your next computer
It's the TOTAL cost to allow you to start making music that is important too, not just the hardware
A quick calculation suggests you would need something like:-
- iMac, 24-inch £1,199
- Apple Logic Studio 8 £270
- An Audio Interface; something like M-Audio Fast Track Pro USB Audio/MIDI Interface £205
That's £1674 !!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Nearly TWO THOUSAND pounds and it's not even the flagship product
It doesn't matter how good it is, it's simply too expensive for many people, but I'm not bitter... Ok maybe a bit!
It would be nice for mere mortals to compete with pros on a level playing field but as this isn't possible it's a case of sticking with Pc's and looking for cheaper software alternatives like Reaper. You can buy a Music capable Pc for less than half the price of a Mac so it's a no brainer.
It would be nice if the music press where to give us more features which reflect the huge number of musicians who must be using Pc setups, be they low to medium to high end
I use a Macbook - it is great for either Garageband or Logic Express and you can mix down on the train.
That's all well and good for Macheads...now how about a similar feature for the rest of us using PCs?
You need to be logged in to post a comment. Login or Register to post a comment.
Good news for those using Akai MPCs alongside their computer music set-ups.
Guess which tattooed Trance producer we've been visiting for our world famous 'In The...
Click to find gear in the following categories:
If you're looking for great deals on gear, tuition, mastering, education or kit hire, click here for our new and improved marketplace.
hypnotica
36 weeks ago.