BLOG: Why GarageBand '09 isn't for music producers

Update focuses on playing rather than recording

If you use Apple's GarageBand for music production purposes, the announcement of the 2009 version of the software probably left you feeling rather disappointed.

Truth be told, there's not much (anything?) in the update that will improve GarageBand's performance as a DAW - many of us probably won't bother to upgrade this time – and I think there are a couple of reasons why Apple has focused its attention on other aspects of the software.

On the one hand, it needs to ensure that it doesn't start to cannibalise sales of its Logic products. If Apple specs GarageBand too well, there'll be no real incentive for users to spend money on its more advanced music production software.

"Many of us probably won't bother to upgrade this time."

On the other hand, though, Apple still needs to give existing GarageBand/iLife users a reason to shell out for the new version, and it's done this by going off at something of a tangent.

By including music lessons – and the option to purchase celebrity-hosted tutorials – it's attempting to appeal to people who want to learn to play rather than record.

This, I think, is a canny move, and gives GarageBand an extra dimension. Budding guitarists will also be able to benefit from the new amps and stompboxes that are included.

That said, I do hope that this doesn't mark the end of GarageBand's evolution as a music production tool. Yes, it will always remain a consumer level product, but much of the software's considerable potential remains untapped.

You might like:

Around the web:


Comment on Facebook