tweet

Axl Rose "should join Velvet Revolver"

Fans vote for reunion of GN'R singer and Slash

Chris Vinnicombe, Thu 4 Sep 2008, 3:10 pm UTC

Velvet Revolver with added Axl

Now, who does this remind you of?

View in gallery

MusicRadar users have voted Axl Rose as the best recruit for the currently singer-less hard rock band Velvet Revolver.

This, of course, would essentially reform Guns N' Roses: Axl Rose, guitarist Slash, bassist Duff McKagan and drummer Matt Sorum would all be in the band – the four core members that recorded Guns N' Roses Use Your Illusion I and II albums in 1991.

Over 2000 voters in the MusicRadar poll chose between four suggestions for the next frontman of Velvet Revolver and the results are as follows:

Chris Cornell (ex-Audioslave) 38%
Perry Farrell
(ex-Jane's Addiction) 7%
Sammy Hagar
(ex-Van Halen) 9%
Axl Rose
(still clinging on to Guns N' Roses) 46%

Velvet Revolver have been without a singer since Scott Weiland left in April 2008, and a search for a replacement has been dogged by confusion. Spacehog's Royston Langdon and Lenny Kravitz have both been rumoured, incorrectly, to be joining and bassist McKagan has admitted the recruitment process is proving "tough".

With Guns N' Roses' Chinese Democracy album (featuring only Axl Rose from the original line-up) still yet to be released after nearly 15 years of recording, it's clear that a lot of fans want both bands to cut their losses and reunite.

Have Guns N' Roses lost all credibility?

MusicRadar Editor Michael Leonard comments: "We didn't ask whether Guns N' Roses should reform the classic line-up, as most fans would most likely say yes. What's astonishing is that so many fans want Axl to actually join Velvet Revolver. Whether it would ever happen, I don't know, but maybe Velvet Revolver now have more credibility than Axl's 'who-the-hell-are-they?' version of Guns N' Roses.

"Whatever the band is called, the bottom line is fans want to see Axl Rose and Slash back together - before they're too old and it's too late."

Meanwhile, Guns N' Roses/Velvet Revolver drummer Matt Sorum exclusively told MusicRadar recently that he "is sure" a Guns N' Roses reunion will eventually happen.

Share:
StumbleUpon
Digg
Reddit
Del.icio.us

User comments (6)

  • saulhudson

    Avatar for saulhudson

    Sun 7 Sep 2008, 7:27 pm UTC

    This is bollox, fans wanting Axl in Velvet Revolver are doing so in the hope that G'n'R will reform, Velvet Revolver is NOT G'n'R and never will be
    Despite Slash, Duff, and Matt being members, it's 'Velvet Revolver' it's just a pity they can't find an 'unknown' front man to carry it on, it'd be so much easier for them as a band I suspect, having famous front men is all well and good but your always gonna get comparisons against there former bands etc.
    Out of the guys up for a vote myself I'd go for Cornell.

    Mark as inappropriate

  • mattj

    Avatar for mattj

    Sat 6 Sep 2008, 1:51 pm UTC

    If Axl joined there'd be too many comparisons to GnR. Also based on Slash's autobiography I don't think it would be that long lasting a reunion. At least with Cornell VR might write some new material that could better Libertad and perhaps even Contraband. I could only see things going backwards with Axl (irrespective of how good a singer he may be).

    Mark as inappropriate

  • Ambre

    Avatar for Ambre

    Sat 6 Sep 2008, 2:26 am UTC

    Cornell's voice would fit perfectly with VR's music. Cornell has a unique style and a unique voice. As for Axl, we already know what would be the result of a reunion. Axl joining VR or VR joining GNR...it really doesn't matter.

    Mark as inappropriate

  • Charvel

    Avatar for Charvel

    Thu 4 Sep 2008, 5:43 pm UTC

    Tentacle, you suck!
    Axl is an awesome singer, but however i voted for Chris Cornell 'cause I think that his voice is awesome, and also Cornell's voice sounds more similar to Scott Weiland's.

    Mark as inappropriate

  • thelynxeffect

    Avatar for thelynxeffect

    Thu 4 Sep 2008, 4:57 pm UTC

    tentacle, you are an idiot. VR rock, Axl is god.

    Mark as inappropriate

  • tentacle

    Avatar for tentacle

    Thu 4 Sep 2008, 4:17 pm UTC

    Axl Rose is an awful singer. So it makes sense that he should join Velvet Revolver.

    Mark as inappropriate

You need to be logged in to post a comment. Login or Register to post a comment.

Poll

Ask MusicRadar: you've chosen the shortlist, now pick a winner. What's the best bass guitar under £300?

ReviewFinder

Search by product, brand or manufacturer

Buy here

  • Buy music products with Professional Music Technology
  • Buy music products with Andertons Music Company
  • Buy music products with Red Dog Music
  • Buy music products with Hartnolls Guitars
  • Buy music products with Thomann

MusicRadar Marketplace

If you're looking for great deals on gear, tuition, mastering, education or kit hire, click here for our new and improved marketplace.

Follow us on twitter Sign up for our free newsletter Have your say on the MusicRadar forums