The No.1 website for musicians
This sophisticated drum ROMpler has a sound to match its 'superior' billing
Computer Music, Mon 18 Aug 2008, 11:38 am BST
The big news with SD 2.0 is that it follows the now industry-standard layout, with separate drum kit and mixer views. If you do feel nostalgic for the original version (dfh Superior), the 'main' super-pad screen or 'classic view' can be selected instead, though Toontrack has done away with the convoluted construction pages.
All kit-building now takes place in the main interface, with microphone bleed levels handled on a fader-by-fader basis in the mixer window – clicking the Bleed selector next to a fader opens up an additional Levels tab.
In terms of kit construction, SD 2.0 includes a few basic layouts, and beyond that you can also augment kits with so-called X-Drums. These are essentially extra instruments that you define and allocate samples and mics to – they then appear in the main kit window with a graphic.
You can have a total of 45 kit positions, including those in the presets list, which is pretty impressive and enables truly monstrous designs.
Superior Drummer 2.0's mixer is incredibly well-equipped. With five inserts per channel, 16 routable busses, phase reverse, and mute and solo on all channels, it feels much like a typical DAW.
It's worth mentioning that the mixer retains the Bounce facility. This includes various options for rendering SD 2.0's audio output to a set of individual audio files. Factor in the five Sonalksis-designed effects (filter, gate, EQ, compressor and transient) and you can do much of your sound-shaping within SD2.0.
In typical DAW style, each effect opens its own small window, which floats within SD2.0's mixer page. All five have familiar interfaces, and wouldn't look out of place in Cubase or Logic. Impressively, you can sidechain within SD 2.0's effects using channels and busses.
Although there's nothing immensely complex about any of the effects, in use, the compressor sounds particularly good. It's also nice to see a transient-tweaking processor, as these are great for shaping both close miked hits and drum ambiences.
In terms of sheer power, the filter's Rude setting enables some very aggressive sound-shaping.
SD2.0 ships with the first volume of Toontrack's New York Studio Legacy Series library, which was recorded at NY's Avatar Studios (formerly The Power Station) by Pat Thrall, Neil Dorfsman and drummer Nir Z. It's a 60GB library, reduced to 20GB on disk using lossless data compression. There are also three slimmed down installs available, 4GB being the smallest.
With the full install, you get to choose which sticks (sticks, brushes, rods or mallets) and kick beater (wood, plastic or felt) to use. The basic kit comes from US company GMS, but is augmented by additional pieces.
You get three kicks, seven snares (including a Ludwig Black Beauty), three hi-hats, four rides, five cymbal sets, two types of tom and a cowbell. For added variety, the kit sample recordings include some additional microphone options. These were processed at source to retain phase coherence, and include an 1176-processed snare mic and another with Shure Green Bullet-recorded room ambience, processed via a Boogie amp.
Finally, as well as overheads, there are five room mic options, recorded with Coles, U67 and C24 mics, among others. However, given the additional memory required, not all of these load automatically, even when you fire up the full kit. Once we got the hang of this, the level of variety available – even before we reached for the onboard effects – became apparent.








Cockos Reaper 2.0
Harrison Mixbus 2.0
Synesthesia Corporation Mandala 2.0
I own most of the drum VSTs on the market and in terms of realism, ability to mix/alter sounds, compatibility with electronic drums and having a 64 bit version, Superior Drummer is easily the best drum VST on the market -- the one to beat!
I am not sure about the gripes of the last users comments, but I can say this - I own them all - BFD, BFD2, Battery Superior 1 and now Superior 2.0. Under no circumstances can I recommend streaming over loading into RAM. In fact, most reviewers and e-drummers will always go this route due to far stable performance - even on a laptop. Now, what really matters is the sound and although I would like a few more kit pieces, which I have read they will have add on kits for, the sound is far superior to anything else I own and I can even use Superior 1 within it. I do tv, film and some smaller artist label work so a pretty broad spectrum and as of now there is nothing out there that beats Superior 2.0. This thing rocks...
Hmm. You didn't mention anything of the ludicrous installation procedure, which stumped me and a friend for some time. Also, I think the snares don't sound very dynamic, and I personally prefer the ones that come with BFD2.
I'm also not a fan of the way Toontrack do on-the-fly decompression, which just adds to the strain on the system. Applications on Windows can only access 2GB of RAM (or 3GB with the /3gb boot flag) and Applications on OSX are limited to 4GB... so loading an entire kit all to RAM is not feasible. Even still, I would prefer disk-streaming and buffer technology, rather than decompression - decompression just seems to add to the CPU load, whilst streaming through disk-buffers to me seems more efficient - provided you have high speed SATA drives in your computer.
Also one thing is a FACT - BFD2's mixer is "superior" in every way to the Superior 2.0 mixer. The BFD2 mixer allows you as many aux's as you need, and as many effects by extension of the fact that you can load as many aux's as you need. Superior 2 is limited with the amount of aux's you can load, and thus if you really want to get down and dirty, you'll have to route into your host to really get into processing the sounds.
People should bare all these things in mind if they really seek professional drum-tracks... and for those seeking harder drums for heavier music, I'd certainly opt for Joe Baressi Evil Drums (Platinum Samples) and BFD2 over Superior 2 any day.
You need to be logged in to post a comment. Login or Register to post a comment.
Slick performance. Library sounds fantastic. Useful included MIDI library. Top quality mixer and effects. Good standalone option for e-drummers.
Library sounds a little samey. MIDI patterns not integrated into plug-in.
Easy to use, slick as you like, and with a 'superior' sound, SD 2.0 has beaten back the competition to claim its place as perhaps the best drum ROMpler going.
All MusicRadar's reviews are by independent product specialists, who are not aligned to any gear manufacturer or retailer. Our experts also write for renowned magazines such as Guitarist, Total Guitar, Computer Music, Future Music and Rhythm. All are part of Future PLC, the biggest publisher of music making magazines in the world.








Superior Drummer 2.0
ChiCat
Sun 22 Aug 2010, 4:43 am BST
User rating 5 of 5