is this right???>?regarding harmonic/ melodic minor:

[gigga_puppy]

we all apreiciate then input of every one to the topic discussed unfortunetley we have all become side tracked from the origional agenda_ as happens so in any situation where humans are implmented to solve a task_ //_

<<do not even laugh !!>!

Chisa and the rest who have turned this thread into a pary for tabloid appreciators_
need have a serious word//
You are well cultured yes and your "out side the box" style of thinking needs comendation only to the attendees of your funeral.... //_


// this topic is about western music theory applied to western musicical genres and that the historical understanding of the development of the before mentioned is imperative to methodical application in order that accurate and effective produce of authentic western music is achivable before the age of retirement!!!>!

(eg songwriting//write a songwriting// no one can right a song unless they went to public or private school and even then .... its all a big secret)_ .....

i thinhk perhaps i may have to lock the thread and start another if no one has anything constructive left to say_

i have alot to say but i shall withframe as it falls beyond the scope origionally intended for this educational discussion thread_ //

[frankus]

wtf // are you //


talking //

about //

you can't lock //

threads //

any more than you can use punctuation

So what do you still want to discuss?

[gigga_puppy]

I'm new to forums
ill lock the thread //
thankx again to all participants...
speak soon_

[frankus]

yup it's pretty locked now... it was fairly difficult posting because of the lock.

[sfocata]

//-- I found a spare key! --//

it was // under the doormat //

so I let myself in --
made a cup of tea --
and did the washing up --

//

[frankus]

here //

have a Bourbon biscuit // I found them next to the bread bin...

What do you think he means by:

// this topic is about western music theory applied to western musicical genres and that the historical understanding of the development of the before mentioned is imperative to methodical application in order that accurate and effective produce of authentic western music is achivable before the age of retirement!!!>!

I think I know what he means, but he's not exactly right is he? I mean countless song writers might not know the function of a chord they just know some chord shapes that happened to sound good together.

Do we wait here for the discussion to start again or pretend the thread is locked?

[spawn]

testing 1-2-3

[spawn]

Hello! is this thing locked...

[spawn]

Originally Posted by chisa

i have never heard of a harmonic major.

the only reason a harmonic minor exists is to facilitate the a major chord for the cadence V-I.

the harmonic major is the, mirror / involution / inversion, of the harmonic minor scale.



that is how you get the harmonic major..



well i am sorry that i missed this topic all together ..


well maybe next time...


editors Note: this is not a mode, it is a scale in of itself

it also shares the same intervalic formula.

Originally Posted by chisa

the only reason a harmonic minor exists is to facilitate the a major chord for the cadence V-I.

to fully understand this, mirror / involution / inversion, theory you would have to stop thinking old school and understand the new school= 21 century way of thinking..

[sfocata]

Originally Posted by frankus

What do you think he means by:

[color=Gray]// this topic is about western music theory applied to western musicical genres and that the historical understanding of the development of the before mentioned is imperative to methodical application in order that accurate and effective produce of authentic western music is achivable before the age of retirement!!!>!

[color=Black]I think I know what he means, but he's not exactly right is he? I mean countless song writers might not know the function of a chord they just know some chord shapes that happened to sound good together.

Yeah, exactly... western music theory doesn't have any bearing on the production of western music, or any other music.